Nestled on Shelby Street, Café Babette Bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a love for fresh, flavorful, and innovative pastries. This unassuming bakery may be easy to miss, but its reputation for creating some of the most delectable baked goods in Indianapolis has foodies buzzing. Once you step inside, you’ll understand why Café Babette has become a cult favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Operating on a limited schedule—Thursdays from 9:30 AM to 3 PM (or until sold out), Fridays from 8:30 AM to 3 PM (donut day!), and Saturdays from 10:30 AM to 2 PM—this bakery is all about quality over quantity. And trust us, the effort to visit during these hours is well worth it. From flaky croissants to hearty sourdough bread, every item is crafted with precision and love.
Café Babette isn’t just about pastries; it’s an experience. First-timers often describe a sense of discovery when they arrive at the seemingly hidden spot. With minimal signage and limited parking, it might feel like you’ve stumbled upon a secret society of pastry enthusiasts. Pro tip: park across the street and prepare to be amazed.
What sets this bakery apart is its bold and creative approach to flavors. Expect pastries infused with floral notes, unique spices, and unexpected yet delightful combinations that rival even the best NYC bakeries. Whether you’re savoring a sweet creation or indulging in something savory, every bite feels like a revelation.
Customer reviews rave about the freshness, the size of the pastries, and the friendliness of the bakers. It’s not uncommon to see lines stretching out the door, but many recommend preordering online to skip the wait. For those willing to brave the queue, the reward is unparalleled. As one loyal patron puts it: “These are the best pastries you’re ever gonna eat in your life, and it’s not even close.”
If you’re looking for a hidden gem that serves up the best croissants, donuts, and sourdough bread in the city, Café Babette Bakery is your spot. Just be sure to arrive early—you won’t want to miss out on this Indy treasure.
Location: 2627 Shelby St., Indianapolis, Indiana 46203
Hours: Thursdays 9:30 AM – 3 PM, Fridays 8:30 AM – 3 PM, Saturdays 10:30 AM – 2 PM
