For four decades, The Apple Store at Conner Prairie has been a beloved stop for families across Indiana. Located inside the scenic grounds of Conner Prairie in Fishers, this cozy seasonal shop is a true celebration of autumn. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the warm aroma of fresh apples, caramel, and cinnamon — everything that makes Indiana’s fall season so special.
Every treat here is made with care and tradition. Whether you choose a crisp caramel apple dipped right in front of you, a jar of homemade apple butter, or a glass of fresh-pressed cider, you can taste the freshness in every bite. The Apple Store’s team prepares everything on-site, ensuring that every product feels handcrafted and full of flavor. It’s a little slice of old-fashioned charm right here in Indiana.
This season, The Apple Store is open evenings from 5–9 p.m. during the popular Headless Horseman event at Conner Prairie. Visitors can enjoy a warm cup of cider or a caramel apple while taking in the lights, music, and Halloween excitement that fill the air. It’s the perfect way to experience the magic of fall nights in Noblesville — delicious, cozy, and full of community spirit.
2025 marks the 40th anniversary of The Apple Store at Conner Prairie — a milestone that highlights just how cherished this place has become. For generations, Indiana families have made it a tradition to stop by every fall, sharing smiles, stories, and sweet moments over freshly made apple treats. It’s not just a store; it’s a piece of Indiana’s heart.
Here’s one more reason to celebrate — October 31 is National Caramel Apple Day! There’s no better place to honor this delicious holiday than The Apple Store at Conner Prairie. Grab one of their famous caramel apples, freshly dipped and coated to perfection, and enjoy the ultimate fall flavor that makes this season unforgettable.
Whether you’re attending the Headless Horseman festivities or simply craving a taste of autumn, The Apple Store at Conner Prairie is a must-visit destination this season. Bring your friends, your family, and your sweet tooth, and experience why this little shop has been an Indiana favorite for 40 years.
WE LIKE INDY Tip: Don’t leave without trying their classic caramel apple with nuts — it’s a seasonal favorite that perfectly captures the magic of fall in Indiana!
Photos by We Like Indy Team.
Marketing
